Counter / Mile End
Pizza Toni
SLICE FIRST, BAGEL AFTER
Falafel Yoni's New York-style slice shop: thin pepperoni slices, grandma squares and spicy-honey pies, from $5.50 a slice.
- From home
- 13 min drive
- Spend
- $$$$
- Our dates
- Open Tue-Thu. Mon holiday hours unconfirmed
The verdict
Go, for a cheap, fast lunch or a slice before a night out, not a long dinner. Get a Toni pepperoni slice and a square, share a whole S.G.H.P. if you're hungry, and add the $3 cookie. It's counter service and gets busy at peak times, so expect a line. Saint-Henri has the same menu and hours if we're on that side of town.
- From Alessia's list
- On Tastet's list of the best pizzas in Montréal (updated June 2026)
- Open daily on posted regular hours at Mile End and Saint-Henri (Thanksgiving Monday still to confirm)
- Cheap and quick: slices $5.50-6.50, whole 14-inch pies $24-28
- Recent diners keep praising the thin, crisp New York-style crust
Order this
Tap the circle to want it. Tap again once it's eaten.
Pizza Toni, the short list
Must order
S.G.H.P. (spicy honey garlic pepperoni)
$26Tomato sauce, garlic oil, chili flakes, grana padano, mozzarella, fior di latte, pepperoni and basil, finished with house-made spicy honey.
Tastet's West Island review names it on the menu, and a recent diner fresh from a month of New York pizza rated it a standout. Hot honey on pepperoni is the house signature move.
Must order
Toni Pepperoni slice
$6Tomato sauce, oregano, mozzarella and pepperoni on the thin New York-style base.
The baseline test for any New York slice shop, and the cheapest way to see what the fuss is about.
Must order
Square pepperoni slice
$6.50Grandma-style sheet-pan square: marinara, garlic oil, oregano, double mozzarella and pepperoni on a parmesan crust.
The other half of the house style. Order one next to a round slice and compare.
Sweet Cherry Pie
$26Tomato sauce, oregano, grana padano, mozzarella, goat cheese, basil and sun-dried cherry tomatoes, finished with a spicy honey swirl. The menu suggests ordering it on the sesame crust.
Several recent diners single it out (via Restoenligne). Goat cheese and hot honey make it the sweet-savoury pick.
Vodka Pep
$28Vodka sauce, mozzarella, fior di latte, grana padano, oregano, chili flakes, pepperoni and spicy honey.
The richest pie on the board. Recent diners are split between loving it and finding it just okay.
Pep d'Ail on the sesame crust
$26Garlic oil, oregano, grana padano, fior di latte, mozzarella, basil, dollops of marinara and pepperoni on a sesame crust with hot honey.
Tastet's favourite thing here is the sesame crust, a nod to Montréal bagels and to Saint-Viateur Street. This pie comes on it by default.
Chocolate chip cookie
$3House-made chocolate chip cookie.
A new addition (Tastet, Oct 2026) that has already drawn praise as a rich, salty-sweet cookie. Three dollars; just get one.
What people actually say
Recurring themes, not cherry-picked quotes.
Love
- The crust comes up again and again: thin, crisp-bottomed New York-style slices with a well-balanced tomato sauce
- The spicy-honey pies get singled out, the Sweet Cherry Pie most of all
- Many recent diners call it their favourite pizza in Montréal, and Tastet keeps it on its best-pizza list
- Counter service is mostly described as fast and friendly
Know before you go
- Some find it pricey for slices
- Occasional inconsistency: a few reports of lukewarm slices or an overdone pie
- A handful of complaints about attitude at the counter and slow delivery
- Waits at busy times
- Counter service: the official site offers no reservations, only walk-in, online orders and phone orders for pickup
- Thanksgiving Monday (Oct 12) is unconfirmed: the official site posts normal Monday hours but no holiday notice
- Specialty pies come whole (14- or 18-inch); by the slice it's cheese, margherita, Toni pepperoni, three squares and a slice of the day
Dishes that keep coming up
Sweet Cherry Pie, Cheese slice, Vodka pepperoni, S.G.H.P. (spicy honey garlic pepperoni), Square slices, Chocolate chip cookie, Sesame crust
- Room
- A bright, Brooklyn-style slice shop designed by Menard Dworkind, with big windows, orange accents, a wooden wall and Dan Climan's artwork. Tastet says the look carries across the branches. The room description dates from Tastet's 2020 Mile End review.
- Service
- Mostly described as quick and friendly, with a few complaints about attitude at the counter. The owners reply to most online reviews.
- Value
- Slices are $5.50-6.50 and whole 14-inch pies $24-28 on the official menu. Most diners think it's worth it; a minority call it pricey for pizza.
Vibe check
casual/bright/buzzy
Best fora quick, cheap lunch in Mile End, a slice before drinks, a pizza night in, with pickup
How much we'll spend
Official menu (Oct 2026): slices $5.50-6.50, whole 14-inch pies $24-28, 18-inch $33-38, house beers $7, soft drinks $2.50, cookie $3. Two slices and a soft drink is about $14-16 a person; half an 18-inch pie and a beer is about $24-26.
On our dates
Daily 11:30am-9pm, Fri-Sat until 10pm
- Mon 12Maybe
- Tue 13Open
- Wed 14Open
- Thu 15Open
Thanksgiving MondayNo Thanksgiving notice on the official site (re-read Oct 9, 2026), and posted hours show Monday as a normal trading day. The earlier note about Oct 12 ordering slots could not be re-verified (ordering app is not readable without a browser). Likely open, but unconfirmed. Instagram not checked. Call (514) 742-4232 on the day.
Full week
| Mon | 11:30am to 9pm |
|---|---|
| Tue | 11:30am to 9pm |
| Wed | 11:30am to 9pm |
| Thu | 11:30am to 9pm |
| Fri | 11:30am to 10pm |
| Sat | 11:30am to 10pm |
| Sun | 11:30am to 9pm |
Make a night of it
Dinner, drinks, late night. Real walking times between.
Pair it with
- St-Viateur Bagel's flagship at 263 Rue Saint-Viateur Ouest, on the same street, for the sesame bagels the sesame crust nods to (check its hours)
- Falafel Yoni, the same owners' falafel shop, if one of us would rather have falafel (check its location and hours)
Where
104 Rue Saint-Viateur Ouest, Montréal, QC H2T 2L1
Counter-service slice shop. The official site has no reservation option: walk in, order online for pickup or delivery (delivery is handled by Uber Eats drivers and the shop recommends pickup), or call (514) 742-4232 to order for pickup.
While you're there
The receipt
Where every fact on this page comes from.
Fact-checkedResearched and independently re-checked Oct 8, 2026, 4 details corrected. Confidence: high.
Details to confirm
- Is Pizza Toni open on Thanksgiving Monday, Oct 12, 2026? The ordering system showed Oct 12 slots at Mile End and Saint-Henri on Oct 8, but there is no explicit holiday notice. Check Instagram @thepizzatoni, call (514) 742-4232, or look at the order page that morning.
- Which branch did Alessia mean? Probably the original Mile End shop; Saint-Henri has the same menu and hours.
- Square pies cost $1 less on the online ordering menu ($37-43) than on the website menu ($38-44); confirm in-store prices.
- Which pie is the slice of the day during our visit?
- Recent reviews of the Saint-Henri branch were not checked.
- Web search was unavailable for this run, so other editorial coverage (Cult MTL, The Main, Gazette) and Reddit threads were not reviewed.
- OfficialPizza Toni (official website): Homepage: menu with prices, three locations, hours, pickup phone (updated Oct 8, 2026 per sitemap)
- OfficialPizza Toni (official website): Order Now: online ordering links per location and delivery notice
- OfficialPizza Toni official online ordering (Lightspeed), Mile End shop: Pizza Toni - St-Viateur: menu items with descriptions and prices, hours, order-ahead dates Oct 8-15 (public ordering data, no login)
- OfficialPizza Toni official online ordering (Lightspeed), Saint-Henri shop: Pizza Toni - Notre-Dame: address, hours, order-ahead dates Oct 8-15
- OfficialPizza Toni official online ordering (Lightspeed), West Island shop: Pizza Toni West Island: address, hours (closed Mon-Tue), order-ahead dates Oct 8-15
- EditorialTastet: Pizza Toni: A Third Pizzeria in the West Island (Oct 8, 2026)
- EditorialTastet: Pizza Toni: A New York Slice Joint by Falafel Yoni (Aug 2020, updated Sep 2021; place card shows current hours)
- EditorialTastet: The Best Pizzas in Montreal (updated June 24, 2026)
- CommunityRestoenligne: Reviews for Pizza Toni (Mile End; Google reviews Aug-Sep 2026 and review summary)
- From usAlessia's list (screenshot supplied by the traveller): Pizza Toni
- OfficialSt-Viateur Bagel (official website): Our stores: flagship at 263 Saint-Viateur St. West, open every day 6am-midnight